This article illuminates an important, ongoing debate between textualist and purposivist theories of statutory interpretation by identify. In particular, this handout will address what to do before you begin interpreting a statute part i, tools of statutory interpretation part ii, and theories of statutory. The study of statutory interpretation moved to the forefront of scholarly attention in the 1980s in large part because legal scholars began to use insights and methodologies from political sciencemost fruitfully, from public choice and other positive theories of politics. The hon michael kirby ac cmg statutory interpretation has replaced the analysis of judicial reasons about the common law as the most important task ordinarily performed by australian lawyers. A guide to reading, interpreting and applying statutes. The fifth edition also updates the books classic and pathbreaking treatment of the theories and practice of statutory interpretation. Statutory interpretation approaches and rules applied 1. Principles of interpretation of statutes 205 process of ascertaining the meaning at an act of parliament or of a provision of an act. Theories of statutory interpretation outlines and revision materials. This article thus reframes the theory of statutory and constitutional interpretation, distinguishing purely linguistic questions from legal questions to which. The modern approach to statutory interpretation jeffrey barnes the widespread realisation that legislation is the cornerstone of the modern legal system justice mchugh has brought increased judicial and scholarly attention to. The modern approach to statutory interpretation jeffrey barnes the widespread realisation that legislation is the cornerstone of the modern legal system justice mchugh has brought increased judicial and scholarly attention to legislations partner, statutory interpretation. Click download or read online button to get statutory interpretation book now. Today, statutes make up the bulk of the relevant law heard in federal courts and arguably represent the most important source of american law.
This article thus reframes the theory of statutory and constitutional interpretation. The two main theories of statutory interpretation purposivism and textualismdisagree about how. In the us, this canon has grown stronger in recent history. And purposivist theories of statutory interpretationand the irreducible roles of values and judgment within both richard h. Theories, tools, and trends april 5, 2018 open pdf 1mb regardless of their interpretive theory, judges use many of the same tools to gather evidence of statutory meaning. The basic principles governing statutory interpretation are repeatedly stated, without apparent disagreement, in decisions of the high court of australia. We argue that legal interpretive rules are conceptually possible, normatively sensible, and actually part of our legal system. Theories, tools, and trends april 5, 2018 open pdf 1 mb regardless of their interpretive theory, judges use many of the same tools to gather evidence of statutory meaning. Theories of legislation 1 pluralismpublic choice theory pluralism. The ideal test would involve presenting randomly selected cases to two judges who are similar in most other respects but. Theories, tools, and trends congressional research service 1 introduction no vehicles in the park. Statutes are products of competing and interacting interest groups, and certain groups interests will be shut out.
Three symmetries between textualist and purposivist theories. Implications of public choice theory for statutory interpretation william n. This was inevitable as the amount of law made by, or under, legislation increased and the room for the residual common law narrowed. This failure has serious consequences in the field of statutory interpretation. Theories of legislation and statutory interpretation open scholarship. Volume 6 issue 1 james allan skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. The ideal test would involve presenting randomly selected cases to two judges who are similar in most other respects but have sharply different theories of interpretation. The report concludes by exploring developing issues in statutory interpretation. The conventional theories of statutory interpretation, sometimes also referred to as interpretative approaches, are both explanatory and justificatory in this way. Statutory interpretation download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl. Statutory interpretation is the process by which courts interpret and apply legislation. The evolutio11 of the principles of statutory interpretation is traced in some detail by corry in adlninistvative law nrzd the intevfivetaiion of the statutes in 286312. The theory and practice of statutory interpretation.
I have shared brief and tothe point notes that will help you revise this subject in quick time. Jurisprudential perspectives on statutory interpretation the general principles of hermeneutics the influence of certain modern critical theories the critical legal studies movement cls deconstruction the linguistic turn south african theories of interpretation the orthodox textbased approach page xii the textincontext approach the. Students may choose to write a short research paper on any one of the questions presented. In the beginning, judges created the literal rule of construction. Start studying economic theories of statutory interpretation pages 593624. Ferejohn and others published a positive theory of statutory interpretation find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Statutory interpretation is a practical guide to the techniques and reasoning used by lawyers and judges to resolve interpretation problems.
Interpretation of statutes pdf notes, ebook for law llb. Theories of constitutional interpretation modern democracy invites us to replace the notion of a regime founded upon laws, of a legitimate power, by the notion of a regime founded upon the legitimacy of a debate as to what is legitimate and what is illegitimatea debate which is necessarily without any guarantor and without any end. Brett, peter the theory of interpreting statutes 1953 uqlawjl. Textualism formalism the conventional approach to statutory interpretation has involved an eclectic mix of reliance on text, canons of interpretation, legislative history, purpose, and public policy. First, judges often begin by looking to the ordinary meaning of the statutory text. The irony of the learned judges interpretation of the very constitutional provision dealing with the prescribed manner of interpretation of statutory provisions, where he refers to and in leans upon the derived afgeleide intention of the legislature, is evident and not insignificant. Weingast hoover institution, stanford university, stanford.
For decades, lawyers have debated the proper scope of this hypothetical law. Statutory interpretation and decision theory cates a dramatic shift in interpretive authority from courts to agencies. Written constitutions and statutes provide authoritative directions for officials and citizens within liberal democracies. The report concludes by exploring developing issues in statutory. Congress should engage in publicspirited interpretation. Michelman says of these theories that they constitute a kind of standard list of interpretative approaches or methods available. Constitutional interpretation refers to the authoritative. A significant precondition to thoughtful legisprudence is critical analysis of different theories explaining the legislative process. Some theories are more or less explicit about this point. Factors which have influenced the shift in the mode of statutory interpretation are. Ferejohn and others published a positive theory of statutory interpretation find, read and cite all the research. Study unit 1 ios 2601 introduction 3 clauses in the supreme constitution that influence interpretation apart from the constitutional values, the interpretation of statutes was transformed by six provisions of the constitution in particular. Statutory interpretation approaches to statutory interpretation 2. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want.
Interpretation of statutes and principles of legislation. The interpretation of statutes is one of the most important subject usually taught in law llb 3rd year. Theories, tools, and trends congressional research service summary in the tripartite structure of the u. These rules each take different approaches to interpretation of a statute. The theory and practice of statutory interpretation frank b. List of key topics covered in interpretation of statutes pdf notes, ebook for law llb students. According to the author, they involve deriving meaning from close consideration of the text, context and purpose policy of any contested provisions.
The proper means of judicial interpretation of those statutes have been the subject of great attention and dispute over the years. I believe that i am on strong ground in claiming that theories of legal interpretation seek to ascertain how statutory and constitutional provisions and other legal instruments affect the content of the law. We also stock outlines on legislation and statutory interpretation as well as law outlines generally. Below are discussed seven originalist theories of constitutional interpretation, four nonoriginalist ones, and two of a hybrid character. A statute presumptively has no extraterritorial application statuta suo. When statutory law is altered during the pendency of a lawsuit, the courts at every level must apply the new law unless doing so would violate the presumption against retroactivity. On the first day of each week, we will discuss major theories of statutory interpretation. Needless to say, such an approach will necessarily require more problembased examples during lectures and contact sessions. This book provides new insights into the theory and practice of statutory interpretation by courts. This fifth edition is not only the product of more than three decades efforts including misguided visions and mistakes to teach interpretation of statutes to. Lesson objectives i will be able to explain the 4 approaches to statutory interpretation i will be able to use cases to illustrate the rules of statutory interpretation 3.
The traditional avoidance canon required the court to choose a different interpretation only when one interpretation was actually unconstitutional. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. These theories derive from approaches to interpretation akin to our own commonlaw theories of statutory interpretation. When no agency is in the picture, vermeule urges judges to eschew the quest for interpretive perfection in favor of keeping decision costs low pp 19296. The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the pdf sample above. Some amount of interpretation is often necessary when a case involves a statute. The book deciphers the complex rules of interpretation, explains the way these rules relate to each other, and focuses on their strategic use constructing arguments and justifying outcomes. Theories of statutory interpretation spring 2015 most modern law is contained in statutes and administrative regulations, which lawyers tend to confront alongside case law in almost every area of practice. Download interpretation of statutes and principles of legislation book pdf for 2nd year students. The article mentions that descriptive and normative theories connect with each other in critical respects. The report then briefly describes the two primary theories of interpretation employed today, before examining the main types of tools that courts use to determine statutory meaning.
This is an extract of our theories of legislation document. The two predominant theories of statutory interpretation today are purposivism and textualism. Is intentionalist theory indispensable to statutory interpretation. Statutory interpretation has been a fertile area of scholarship, but we know relatively little about the practical impact of various theories of interpretation. But in many cases, there is some ambiguity or vagueness in. All metaphors aside, then, the law of a statute resides in the. Preliminary steps there are three important preliminary steps you should take before attempting to interpret a given statute. Pdf a positive theory of statutory interpretation researchgate.
Theories of legislation and statutory interpretation. Interpretation of statutes and principles of legislation book pdf. This is an extract of our theories of legislation document, which we sell as part of our legislation and statutory interpretation outlines collection written by the top tier of university of pennsylvania law school students. Statutory interpretation download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Theories of statutory interpretation please read corcoran 2005, extract in the reader and answer the following questions.
Sometimes the words of a statute have a plain and a straightforward meaning. Pdf statutory interpretation download full pdf book download. Theories of statutory interpretationintentionalism. Economic theories of statutory interpretation pages 593624. Three symmetries between textualist and purposivist. Students will present an argument for and against a specific proposition for the week. Legislation and statutory interpretation oxford handbooks.
A unified theory of statutory interpretation oxford academic journals. A n important question of positive and normative legislation theory is what role courts should assume when they interpret statutes as opposed to the constitution and the common law. In terms of which theory has tended to predominate in american legal history, the pattern in statutory interpretation as well as in constitutional law and common. Economic theories of statutory interpretation pages 593. Pdf statutory interpretation download full pdf book. It is desirable to begin with justice oconnors approach to constitutional interpretation, for all the approaches to be discussed later either derive from it or react against it. A decision theory of statutory interpretation yale law school. Statutory interpretation approaches and rules applied.
Second, courts interpret specific provisions by looking to. Constitutional and statutory interpretation oxford handbooks. Apr 05, 2018 the two predominant theories of statutory interpretation today are purposivism and textualism. We have a law of civil procedure, criminal procedure, and administrative procedure, but we have no law of legislative procedure. This article discusses relatively established theories with respect to statutory and constitutional interpretation. Pdf the theory and practice of statutory interpretation. Theories of statutory interpretation oxbridge notes. Jul 03, 2019 interpretation of statutes and principles of legislation book pdf.
1405 541 1476 450 1057 735 903 663 346 160 285 1484 793 259 178 1463 170 370 1152 1464 598 265 82 93 1283 1472 227 781 1162 932 689 1262 135 869 16 1305 851 1409 748